Today I want to share a suspected scam we encountered while selling wall decals on Etsy. I began to suspect that buyers were using AI to add damage to product photos. We received three similar complaints in the past month and reviewed some of our processes in the print workshop and our communication with customers.
It started with an ordinary order for a large wall decal. We printed it, rolled it carefully, packed it in a sturdy, long rectangular box and shipped it to a customer in the US. The parcel arrived quickly and tracking confirmed delivery. A few days later, the customer demanded a full refund. They said the product and its packaging had been badly damaged in transit.
The customer attached a photo to the message. It showed our box with a deep cut, as if someone had dragged a utility knife through the cardboard, and the vinyl decal inside also appeared to be cut. I was about to refund the order as usual to protect the shop's record and avoid spending time on a dispute. But something about the photo bothered me, so I took a closer look.
When I enlarged the image, I noticed some strange details. The angle of the cut in the box did not line up with the cut in the rolled decal. The cardboard edges looked blurred and the shadows fell at an odd angle. I suspected that someone had used AI to add damage to the photo, hoping to get a refund and keep the intact product. That was my reading of the image, not a forensic finding.
A few days later, the same thing happened again. Another complaint about a torn box arrived with a photo showing packaging that looked as if a dog had chewed it, but the cardboard texture looked strange when enlarged. I checked the addresses and found the same postal code under different recipient names. Together with the similar complaints, that raised my suspicions, although a shared postal code alone proves nothing.
This time, I decided to investigate first and wrote the customer a polite reply. I explained that we needed the damaged item back for inspection before pursuing an insurance claim with FedEx. I sent a prepaid return label. I promised a full refund as soon as the cut decal and its box came back to us.
After that, the customer stopped replying. The decal was never returned. They did not open an official Etsy case either. That gave me another reason to question the complaint.
We now ask for more than one photo before deciding on a refund for serious physical damage. We request a short video showing the damaged item and the box being turned around, or ask for the item back for inspection. A video is an additional check, not a guarantee that the evidence is genuine. I hope this experience helps other sellers look more closely at similar claims and protect their money.