Wall decals on Etsy and a disputed 300 dollar refund

A man sits behind a laptop in a printing workshop. Boxes, sheets of labels, documents, a phone and a mug are on the table.

Recently, I shared a story about a way sellers can be deceived on marketplaces. Less than two weeks later, something similar happened in our own shop while selling wall decals on Etsy. I want to explain what happened so other business owners know what to look for.

One customer placed two separate orders. The first was for a simple wall decal costing 50 dollars, and the second was for a large, complex decal costing 300 dollars. We made and packed everything, then sent two parcels with separate tracking numbers because the delivery addresses were different. Both parcels reached their stated destinations.

The customer then contacted us about the 50 dollar decal. They said it was not the design they had ordered. We followed our usual process and asked for a photo so we could investigate and resolve the problem. The customer photographed the cheaper decal, but what happened next surprised us.

Instead of continuing the conversation or opening a case about the 50 dollar order, the customer opened a case about the 300 dollar order. They claimed that the item did not match the description. As evidence, they attached the photo of the cheaper decal from the first order. The photo did show a different product from the expensive listing, but it belonged to a different purchase.

Etsy closed the case in the buyer's favour and issued a refund. To us, it looked as if the system had compared the photo with the listing without connecting it to the right order. I do not know who made the decision or what checks took place inside Etsy. What I do know is that all 300 dollars came out of our account, while the customer kept both decals and received the money for the expensive order back. We believe evidence from one purchase was used to misrepresent another, and we are challenging the decision.

There is a separate point about Etsy Purchase Protection. Under the current rules, eligible orders can receive up to 250 dollars in coverage even when the order total is higher. That coverage was not applied in our case, and we were charged the full refund. The 300 dollar order value alone therefore does not explain the full charge.

We are still working through this with Etsy support. We are submitting appeals with screenshots of the messages, both tracking numbers and the parcel weights. We want a person to match each order to its product and to the photo in the complaint. The issue is unresolved, and I do not know how it will end.

I am sharing this to warn other business owners. Pay attention when one person places several orders with very different prices and different delivery addresses. Check which order the complaint concerns and which product the evidence actually shows.

See Decords in Action