Someone recently asked whether I had tried selling on Amazon with products other than our wall decals. They meant the familiar model of buying stock in China and reselling it. Yes, I had. My first attempt taught me to count every cent.
This was about six years ago. I already understood Amazon warehouses through our decal business, so I took courses, paid for Helium 10 and started looking for a product. My criteria came straight from the textbook. It had to be simple, durable, small enough to ship cheaply and useful in every home.
After searching through many ideas in Black Box, I found what seemed like the perfect product. These were metal shower curtain rings with rollers that helped the curtain glide without scratching the rail. Demand was growing, and the niche looked promising.
I contacted about 50 suppliers on Alibaba. Thirty replied, ten accepted a small order of 100 units, and three offered a suitable price. I had samples sent to Estonia, chose a supplier and designed my own packaging with Amazon barcodes. Then I sent the first 100 units to a US warehouse.
At first, nothing sold. Advertising got things moving but ate up all the profit, and the first 100 units sold in a month. I ordered 300, then 500, and sales without advertising started coming in. The reports finally showed a profit, so ordering more seemed the obvious next step.
After three or four months, sales stopped. A larger advertising budget did not help, and competitors were selling the same product in similar packaging for less. I cut my price, they cut theirs again, and I ordered their product to check it. The rings looked identical, and I concluded they came from the same factory. My suspicion was that the supplier had noticed the demand and started selling directly or through other sellers.
Then the numbers caught up with me. A pack sold for $7.99, Amazon fees took about $5, and the product plus shipping cost $2. That left roughly 99 cents before advertising. A 50 cent price cut removed about half of that, and advertising could take the result to zero or below. With so little room, competing with the factory on price made no sense.
I sold the remaining stock and left the niche. My lesson was that cheap products with a low barrier to entry were not the right model for me, because someone could easily beat my price. I needed a more complex, more expensive product with a larger margin. I found one later, but that is another story.