Why I stopped dropshipping between Amazon and eBay

A man in a yellow sweater holding a white cup in front of a light coloured wall.

About a month ago, someone asked whether I had ever tried classic dropshipping while selling on marketplaces. Yes, I had. Today I want to share my experience of dropshipping between Amazon and eBay, a business built on the price difference between the two platforms.

The idea was to find the same product at different prices, buy it cheaply on one platform and sell it for more on the other. The difference was supposed to be mine. I took another course that explained how to find suitable products, automate the process and earn money without ever holding the goods. It sounded like an excellent system, so I decided to test it.

There were two main approaches, and I tried both. First, I found products available at good prices in Amazon FBA warehouses and listed them on eBay. When a customer bought one, I placed a regular Amazon order with delivery straight to that buyer. My first mistake was forgetting to disable international shipping on eBay. When someone from another country ordered, I discovered that Amazon either could not deliver there or charged a fortune for shipping.

Then came the problems with returns. If a product arrived damaged, the customer wanted to send it back. I did not want to give them Amazon's return address because they would immediately see where it came from and could discover the original price. I had to look for warehouses in the US to handle the return in between, which added more costs.

I also tried the opposite approach, finding cheap products on eBay and selling them on Amazon. The margins could be higher, but the risks were even greater. Many of the sellers I bought from shipped their goods from China. Delivery often took longer than I had promised on Amazon, and customers complained. Sometimes the product also failed to match its description exactly.

The biggest nightmare was a product going out of stock. Someone would buy from me on Amazon, but when I went to eBay to purchase the item, it was already gone. With software managing hundreds or thousands of listings, keeping up with other sellers' inventory proved extremely difficult. Popular products sold out quickly, and I regularly had orders I could not fulfil. Trying to agree on cancellations with buyers did not solve the underlying problem.

Cancelling orders because stock is unavailable harms a seller's performance metrics on Amazon. There is no universal rule that two or three cancellations automatically lead to a ban. It is the proportion of cancelled orders that matters, and a few cases can have a large effect when sales volume is low. Eventually, I received a serious warning that my cancellation rate had exceeded the allowed level. The message said that another breach could result in my account being closed.

As I looked into it further, I realised that the business model itself was also a problem. eBay does not allow buying a product from another retailer or marketplace after a sale and having it shipped directly to the buyer. Amazon permits dropshipping under specific conditions, including identifying you as the seller in the accompanying paperwork and making you responsible for returns. My system of placing ordinary orders on other platforms gave me no reliable control over meeting those requirements.

I decided to stop risking my accounts for this business model. I turned off the software, closed the project and stopped investing my time in it. My accounts were not blocked, but I had more than enough stress. For me, it was a useful lesson that scaling sales without real control over the goods could become a game of roulette.

See Decords in Action